These 10 tips will make your fall open house a smashing success.
Get them here
Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?

Best Sandwich Places in Hilton Head Island

Michael Gonzalez



May 9 4 minutes read

Eating a sandwich can reveal a lot about one’s personality. Some like to cut the sandwich in half and eat from the center out, while some people like to slice it diagonally and begin with the corners. Some prefer their sandwich grilled, while others want it toasted. Whatever your preferences are when it comes to eating a sandwich, you'll surely find a lot of restaurants in Hilton Head Island where sandwiches are prepared skillfully and of course, deliciously!

Here are the top places in Hilton Head Island for great-tasting sandwiches.

Stu's Surf Side

1 N Forest Beach Dr., Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

✅Outdoor seating - ✅Sit-down dining

If you're traveling to Hilton Head Island for a weekend reset, it's always a good idea to stop by at Stu's for some "subs and chill" time! Enjoy a menu full of great-tasting submarine sandwiches, all homemade, innovative, and top-notched, salads, soups, and everything else in between. At Stu's Surf Side, you can be sure that everything is fresh, all items in generous servings!

Earle of Sandwich Pub

1 N Forest Beach Dr. - Ste 44, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

✅Outdoor seating - ✅Takeout - ✅Sit-down dining - ✅Curbside pickup

Forty-seven years in the food industry and Earle of Sandwich Pub is still consistently giving patrons the best sandwiches in town! Come by after a quick dip at the beach or for an early dinner with the family, and treat yourselves to some comfort food, great cold drinks, and excellent customer service!

The Downtown Deli

1223 May River Rd., Bluffton, SC 29910

✅Outdoor seating - ✅Takeout - ✅Sit-down dining - ✅Curbside pickup

If you're looking for top-notch sandwiches in different makes and flavors, then you've come to the right place! The Downtown Deli has been serving customers and patrons fresh, unique, and flavorful sandwiches, all in good sizes and affordable prices. Find interesting sides and refreshings salads to go with your meal-- The Downtown Deli also offers numerous non-sandwich menu items that can fill your tummy up any time of the day!

Sprout Momma

21 Cardinal Rd #105, Hilton Head Island SC 29926

✅Outdoor seating - ✅Takeout - ✅Sit-down dining

Sprout Momma offers breakfast and lunch sandwiches using artisan bread. Other menu options include soups, vegan cheeses, and deli prepared salads. It also has a local bakery that features all kinds of cakes such as kids' birthday cakes and wedding cakes. Some of their popular menu items include French Country, Salad Croissant, Artisan Grilled Cheese, Vegan Press, and Philly Press.

Carolina Coffee & Crumbs

101 Pope Ave., Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

✅Outdoor seating - ✅Takeout - ✅Sit-down dining - ✅Curbside pickup

If you're looking for some tasty breakfast, a filling lunch, a quick snack, or an easy dinner, then Carolina Coffee & Crumbs is the way to go! Enjoy homemade pastries, bagels, sandwiches, paninis, salad, and soups, complete with a beautiful, beachy feel every time you dine! Hang out with your buddies and feel the true HHI Southern vibe, and get your tummies feeling filled up and satisfied!

Frosty Frog Cafe

1 N Forest Beach Dr., Coligny Plaza, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

✅Outdoor seating - ✅Takeout - ✅Sit-down dining

Enjoy an extensive menu of daiquiris, salads, wraps, sandwiches, and pizzas at Frosty Frog Cafe! It's known to be one of the best places to eat on the island, and it's got friendly staff and great customer service to boot! Expect good food at a great price only at Frosty Frog!

Jersey Mike's Subs

430 William Hilton Pkwy. - Ste 201, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926

✅Delivery - ✅Takeout

It's all about quality at Jersey Mike's Subs! Get high-quality meats and cheese together with store-baked bread and that unique Jersey Mike taste every single time! Craving for desserts after a tasty sandwich meal? Have a cookie or brownie tray for the perfect finale!

Need Information in Home Buying?

Schedule a 1 on 1 with Michael

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies. More info